By trading the ancient tribal covenant for a failed Western technical dream, MBS lost the loyalty of the men who hold the roads and the blessing of the men who hold the mosques.
This is very informative. I have never knew exactly how the Saudi leadership works. It seems to me that the tribal and clerics have a great set of checks and balances to keep a king in check.
If MBS goes, so will the American influence. NO MBS, no America in the Middle East. NO America in the Middle East, Israel becomes a nuclear-armed mouse in the region. What then?
You have to understand the war between Iran and Israel the US was never really about these 3; but rather, the arrival of an Asiatic global order. Which would shift the power in this region from the western eurocentric system to eastern asiatic structure.
The pendulum of power is already swinging from west to east.
Churchill installed the Saudis. One reason was because they are wahabist Muslim and they have been used for western hegemony for example MBS sending and infiltrating Pakistani madrassahs with extremist teachers etc. as a means of control to destabilise the Pashtuns that have been split down the centre of their ancestral homelands with the fake Durand line. No doubt the tribes and mosques in Saudi Arabia must support the family. But Churchill knew how to handle everyone in the same way as he engineered the “ partition” of India. He knew full well how to use Jinnahs jealousy of Gandhi and his greed to rule. That partition destabilised Kashmir, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Iran, Balochistan( India and the worlds largest tribe the Pashtun. All planned to destabilise and thus weaken the whole area. The lines drawn in the desert by Churchill etc of Iraq, Saudi, Oman, Kuwait, Bahrain all of them was done with the eventual installation of global government in mind. The tribes must help stop all this. And not let one empire play them off against one another, again, as the British did ( do ?) against the Ottomans. In the same way as the cult is doing to the western people to keep them divided against one another so they are not strong enough to resist ( they think ) so they keep the tribes and nations split and warring against one another so they are unable to resist being colonised. Again. The tribes must be clear this time about who the enemy really is if they are going to mount an effective end to it. Perhaps no more Lawrence of Arabia games.
You have excellent knowledge of history and I thank you so much for your input.
I am going to add one more point here.And that is that the war between iran, israel and the USA isn't just about these three actors. It's about the realignment of the region where the eurocentric powers are being replaced with asiatic powers.In this case, china, iran, russia and pakistan.
This shift also indicates that after fifty years, where the arab power dominated the region, from now be dominated by asiatic islamic nations.
And what about Mosaad influence...bc fractured countries are their specialty and or course the CIA. Mosaad runs them. And the CIA runs the ISI in Pakistan. It is greatly to Netanyahus advantage that all this vulnerability happens. I’m deeply concerned about that. I hope that the tribes understand all this and that they have integrity and don’t get bought off but that they will have a care for the people. And love for God overall. Only that will bring a truly liberated and strong independent country. Pakistan is far too weak ( what Churchill intended from the start ) and corrupt to accomplish anything solid. The military regime was installed by Biden when he took out democratically elected Imran Khan bc he went to US sanctioned Russia for wheat for the people. He’s still in prison. I had hoped that trump would get him out but that won’t happen. Trump also called Imran his “ friend “ at one time too. Pakistan will continue to obey US INC. Unless someone makes them a better offer. And it would have to be massive. The regime is hated and they are responsible for the disappearance and torturing of thousands and thousands of people especially Pashtun and Balochis. The last time mostly Pashtun went to Islamabad to protest about Imran Khan the reborn shot and killed over a hundred people. As for nukes it may be another expensive hoax like NASA. Interesting that you mention Islamic nations as separate from Arab nations. There is definitely a difference. Thank you for your kind response, excellent writing. I’ll be reading more.
Mossad has influence within thr hierarchy of the Arab leaderships.
However, Mossad is facing its own internal crisis, including the war.
Also, as powerful as mossad is, it's too late for them to stop the tribes and the army because it may have the upper elite but it is the rank and file that ensure the success of a regime.
As for Pakistan, you have to understand that there is a new power system is emerging where the western eurocentric system is being replaced by asiatic powers.
No one says the kings will be removed tomorrow or next week. But the seed has been planted and it is bearing fruit very quickly.
By the way, thank you for your response and reading my article.
If you are interested in further information, please look at my previous works, particularly my 3-part work on the impact of the war on the US and 4-part on the Levant and the rise of CIR,🇨🇳🇮🇷🇷🇺, Alliance.
Thank you for your report. I've been very curious about MBS control after this fiasco of alliance with the Trump family. I hope he's removed and that every deal made with this curupt family is dissolved.
Thank you for this bold analysis. It appears that what you term the 'broken covenant' is a direct consequence of the shifting continental logic in Eurasia and the obsolescence of traditional security models. MBS has committed significant strategic errors, both internally through his confrontation with the princes and his attempt at a 'revolution from the top down,' and externally through his adversarial stance toward neighboring states.
How was MBS strong support, even outright urging for Trump to attack Iran (Shias) received on the street in KSA (Sunni)? Was there initial support for MBS from the tribal people in the millennial war between Sunni & Shia Islam? Or was there immediate anger that UsIsrael had attacked another Muslim country & MBS should have stayed out of it. There's no doubt that all the GCC are now cursing the catastrophe of letting the USA use their land for bases to attack a powerful neighbor ... but just a bit too late don't you think?
I don't think it's too late for mbs to be removed from power.
He has broken the covenant that sustained his power.
It does not mean he's going to be overthrown tomorrow or next week. But what it means is that the seeds have been planted, and they are already bearing fruits.
Also, thank you so much for reading my article.😊
If you want a more in depth, look into the region and the shift that's occurring from western to asiatic, please free to review my previous works
The House of Saud hid in Yemen while the other Arab tribes fought to liberate their land. They then came out of hiding and took over. I would be surprised if Mi6 wasn't involved in this...
This is very informative. I have never knew exactly how the Saudi leadership works. It seems to me that the tribal and clerics have a great set of checks and balances to keep a king in check.
You made an excellent point. Arab societies, particularly those in the Gulf, have always had a covenant between the king and its subjects.
When the king breaks that covenant, there is no place for that king in the tent.
If MBS goes, so will the American influence. NO MBS, no America in the Middle East. NO America in the Middle East, Israel becomes a nuclear-armed mouse in the region. What then?
In many ways, you're right.
You have to understand the war between Iran and Israel the US was never really about these 3; but rather, the arrival of an Asiatic global order. Which would shift the power in this region from the western eurocentric system to eastern asiatic structure.
The pendulum of power is already swinging from west to east.
I’d say it’s the opposite, if US influence goes so will the house of Saud.
In both cases the influence has gone
Churchill installed the Saudis. One reason was because they are wahabist Muslim and they have been used for western hegemony for example MBS sending and infiltrating Pakistani madrassahs with extremist teachers etc. as a means of control to destabilise the Pashtuns that have been split down the centre of their ancestral homelands with the fake Durand line. No doubt the tribes and mosques in Saudi Arabia must support the family. But Churchill knew how to handle everyone in the same way as he engineered the “ partition” of India. He knew full well how to use Jinnahs jealousy of Gandhi and his greed to rule. That partition destabilised Kashmir, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Iran, Balochistan( India and the worlds largest tribe the Pashtun. All planned to destabilise and thus weaken the whole area. The lines drawn in the desert by Churchill etc of Iraq, Saudi, Oman, Kuwait, Bahrain all of them was done with the eventual installation of global government in mind. The tribes must help stop all this. And not let one empire play them off against one another, again, as the British did ( do ?) against the Ottomans. In the same way as the cult is doing to the western people to keep them divided against one another so they are not strong enough to resist ( they think ) so they keep the tribes and nations split and warring against one another so they are unable to resist being colonised. Again. The tribes must be clear this time about who the enemy really is if they are going to mount an effective end to it. Perhaps no more Lawrence of Arabia games.
You have excellent knowledge of history and I thank you so much for your input.
I am going to add one more point here.And that is that the war between iran, israel and the USA isn't just about these three actors. It's about the realignment of the region where the eurocentric powers are being replaced with asiatic powers.In this case, china, iran, russia and pakistan.
This shift also indicates that after fifty years, where the arab power dominated the region, from now be dominated by asiatic islamic nations.
Zelensky wants Ukraine to be “ Greater Israel “. A pincer movement in progress?
Yes but he won't get it
Regime * not reborn ...that auto spell check 🙄
And what about Mosaad influence...bc fractured countries are their specialty and or course the CIA. Mosaad runs them. And the CIA runs the ISI in Pakistan. It is greatly to Netanyahus advantage that all this vulnerability happens. I’m deeply concerned about that. I hope that the tribes understand all this and that they have integrity and don’t get bought off but that they will have a care for the people. And love for God overall. Only that will bring a truly liberated and strong independent country. Pakistan is far too weak ( what Churchill intended from the start ) and corrupt to accomplish anything solid. The military regime was installed by Biden when he took out democratically elected Imran Khan bc he went to US sanctioned Russia for wheat for the people. He’s still in prison. I had hoped that trump would get him out but that won’t happen. Trump also called Imran his “ friend “ at one time too. Pakistan will continue to obey US INC. Unless someone makes them a better offer. And it would have to be massive. The regime is hated and they are responsible for the disappearance and torturing of thousands and thousands of people especially Pashtun and Balochis. The last time mostly Pashtun went to Islamabad to protest about Imran Khan the reborn shot and killed over a hundred people. As for nukes it may be another expensive hoax like NASA. Interesting that you mention Islamic nations as separate from Arab nations. There is definitely a difference. Thank you for your kind response, excellent writing. I’ll be reading more.
Mossad has influence within thr hierarchy of the Arab leaderships.
However, Mossad is facing its own internal crisis, including the war.
Also, as powerful as mossad is, it's too late for them to stop the tribes and the army because it may have the upper elite but it is the rank and file that ensure the success of a regime.
As for Pakistan, you have to understand that there is a new power system is emerging where the western eurocentric system is being replaced by asiatic powers.
No one says the kings will be removed tomorrow or next week. But the seed has been planted and it is bearing fruit very quickly.
By the way, thank you for your response and reading my article.
If you are interested in further information, please look at my previous works, particularly my 3-part work on the impact of the war on the US and 4-part on the Levant and the rise of CIR,🇨🇳🇮🇷🇷🇺, Alliance.
Well Saudi should definitely be siding with Iran
Thank you for your report. I've been very curious about MBS control after this fiasco of alliance with the Trump family. I hope he's removed and that every deal made with this curupt family is dissolved.
Excellent article😎
Thank you so much.😊
I appreciate your input. Please feel free to read my previous works to have a more indepth look of this region.
Amazing article! Thank you.🙏
Thank you.😊 I am glad u enjoyed it.
If you want a more comprehensive view, please read my previous works or watch my videos.
Ok!
insightful
Thank you very much 😊
Thank you for this bold analysis. It appears that what you term the 'broken covenant' is a direct consequence of the shifting continental logic in Eurasia and the obsolescence of traditional security models. MBS has committed significant strategic errors, both internally through his confrontation with the princes and his attempt at a 'revolution from the top down,' and externally through his adversarial stance toward neighboring states.
Thank you for your comments and reading my article.
If you want further insights, please feel to review my previous work
so, has Trump indeed brought about regime change, but in Saudi Arabia instead of Iran?
In many ways, yes
By the way, thank you so much for reading the article and on your input.😊
Maybe he can ask Herod for the billions back.
Reports are that Jordan’s king has also broke trust with his tribal base that allows the monarch to rule with power.
A king is not a king without a tribe or an army, especially when the tribes control that army that controls the border and the state.
https://substack.com/@mrah10/note/p-191518323?r=e4645&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action
How was MBS strong support, even outright urging for Trump to attack Iran (Shias) received on the street in KSA (Sunni)? Was there initial support for MBS from the tribal people in the millennial war between Sunni & Shia Islam? Or was there immediate anger that UsIsrael had attacked another Muslim country & MBS should have stayed out of it. There's no doubt that all the GCC are now cursing the catastrophe of letting the USA use their land for bases to attack a powerful neighbor ... but just a bit too late don't you think?
I don't think it's too late for mbs to be removed from power.
He has broken the covenant that sustained his power.
It does not mean he's going to be overthrown tomorrow or next week. But what it means is that the seeds have been planted, and they are already bearing fruits.
Also, thank you so much for reading my article.😊
If you want a more in depth, look into the region and the shift that's occurring from western to asiatic, please free to review my previous works
Question. Is this why the announcement of the Saudis no longer funding LIV golf?
Partially, yes, and partially because the king has no more money per se.
Great article. MBS got too big for his britches. The elders and the oman reign supreme. The trump family will make them lose everything
The House of Saud hid in Yemen while the other Arab tribes fought to liberate their land. They then came out of hiding and took over. I would be surprised if Mi6 wasn't involved in this...
Maybe, we'll see......🤔🇸🇦🕋🛢️🚢⛽⚖️⏰